NYC Restaurant Guide: The Little Pie Company

Settle into this Hell’s Kitchen gem to get your fill of sweet treats just like Grandma bakes.

The Little Pie Company
Address: 424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Telephone: 212.736.4780  
Cuisine: Bakery
Neighborhood: Hell’s Kitchen, Midtown West

The Little Pie Company, a Hell’s Kitchen gem, serves quick lunches and pre-Theater snacks like ridiculously good Red Velvet cupcakes, Threeberry Pie, Sugarless Apple Pie, and Oven Fresh Muffins. 

The Little Pie Company started baking pies in 1985, in a modest storefront on 43rd Street. Shortly after they opened their doors, New Yorkers started to take notice of the good things that were cooking up inside and passers-by peered through their windows to catch a glimpse of the magic taking place.

While The Little Pie Company is just a bakery, we urge you to try one, or two of their baked goods, pies, muffins, or cakes and you will know why this ‘simple bakery’ made it on our ‘NYC Restaurant Guide.’

The Little Pie Company peels, slices, and arranges their pies, cakes, and other desserts in the middle of the vibrant Theater District. Stop by The Little Pie Company and see the rows and rows of beautifully baked pies, with crusts so golden and pretty they beg to be snatched up and brought home on the spot.

You can enjoy these tasty treasures inside at the counter or at one of the tables outside. During the holidays, linger at the bakery and enjoy a cozy setting complete with seasonal window decorations.\

Use our New York Visitors Blog, to research more about all there is to do, see and experience during your next visit to New York.

For other recommendations, see our list of NYC Things to Do and our NYC Shopping Guide.

For the 'Guaranteed Best Rates' at our Times Square Hotel, view our current Special Offers, Check Rates, Make Reservations, or call: 212.710.7000.

Trays of various kinds of pies